Meet Our Staff


Pastor Beth Farabee

Pastor Beth is a native Floridian who has been in ministry for almost 20 years. She’s a graduate of Florida State University with a degree in Elementary Education and a Masters of Divinity from Duke University.  A few of her favorite things are: her family, friends, going to the movies, live theatre performances, FSU football and, of course, Jesus!


Director of Children, Youth, and Family Ministries
Jesse hails from California. After graduating from North Park Theological Seminary in Chicago, Illinois,  he spent some time with family in both Texas and California. He is delighted to now be a part of the family here at First United Methodist Church. When not serving the church, Jesse can be found watching Doctor Who or the Muppets, or practicing his hook shot for when the Orlando Magic inevitably call him up as their center.


Director of Music Ministries
He holds a Masters in Music-Conducting from Texas Christian University and has pursued a Masters in Sacred Music from Southern Methodist University. 

Cheryl Katterhenry

Finance Manager
Cheryl is the Finance Manager for FUMC. Cheryl and her husband John live in the lovely small town of Keystone Heights on Lake Geneva.  She loves spending time with her three children Christine, Joshua and Winter and three grandchildren Jordan, Christian and Emma.

Lorin Winters

Director of FUMPers Preschool
Graduate of University of Florida with a Masters in Early Childhood Education and mother of two. She enjoys reading, Law and Order, and house-hunting. Lorin has over a decade of experience in the early childhood education field. 

Janet Rocap

Office Manager

Tony Taylor

Facilities Manager


Director of Communications and Community Engagement